Request a Free Roof Inspection →

Back to BlogRoofing

How to Choose a Roofer in Rock County: 9 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Nov 22, 20263 min read
How to Choose a Roofer in Rock County: 9 Questions to Ask Before You Sign

A roof replacement is one of the biggest checks most homeowners write, and in Rock County it often comes right after a storm, when door-knockers show up from three states away. Here are the nine questions we'd ask if we were hiring a roofer, including us.

1. Are you a certified Wisconsin Dwelling Contractor?

In Wisconsin, a contractor generally needs a Dwelling Contractor certification to pull a building permit on a one- or two-family home, and getting certified means showing proof of liability insurance or a bond. Ask for the number and look it up on the Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Services (DSPS) license search. Ours is Dwelling Contractor #4721.

2. Can I see your certificate of insurance?

You want proof of general liability insurance and, if they have employees on your roof, workers' compensation. Ask for the certificate to come straight from their insurance agent. If someone gets hurt or something gets damaged during the job, you don't want any question about who's covered.

3. Where is your business, and how long have you been here?

A local address and local references matter. After a big hail storm, out-of-town crews work a neighborhood for a few weeks and move on. If something goes wrong a year later, you want a roofer you can still reach. Hookset is based in Beloit.

4. What does your workmanship warranty cover, and for how long?

The shingle manufacturer covers the shingles. The workmanship warranty covers the installation itself: the nailing, the flashing, the ventilation. Get it in writing, with the length and what it covers. Ours is 5 years standard, with 10-year, 15-year and lifetime options, and the exact term is written into your proposal.

5. Will you tear off the old roof?

A full tear-off lets the crew see and replace soft or rotted decking before the new roof goes on. Layering new shingles over old ones can hide problems. If a quote doesn't say tear-off, ask.

6. What exactly is in the quote?

A good quote lists the work, not just a total. Look for:

  • Full tear-off and disposal
  • Synthetic underlayment
  • Ice and water shield at the eaves and valleys
  • New drip edge
  • New pipe boots and flashing
  • Ventilation (ridge vent or roof vents)
  • Cleanup, including a magnetic sweep for nails
  • How rotted decking is handled and priced

When two quotes are thousands of dollars apart, the difference is usually somewhere in this list.

7. Who will be on my roof, and who's in charge on site?

Ask who does the actual installation and who you call if something comes up during the job. You should have one person who answers for the whole project.

8. How do deposits and payments work?

A deposit is normal. Paying the full price before any work starts is not. Make sure the payment schedule is written into the contract.

If insurance is paying for the roof, know two things about Wisconsin law. A contractor can't offer to pay or rebate your deductible to win the job, and a contractor can't negotiate your claim for you. If your claim is denied in whole or in part, you can cancel the contract until the end of the third business day after you get the insurer's written denial.

9. How will you document the roof?

Photos protect you, especially when insurance is involved. We fly a drone on every inspection so you can see exactly what we saw. Whoever you hire, ask for photos of any damage or rotted decking they find.

Red flags

  • Shows up uninvited right after a storm and pushes you to sign that day
  • Offers to "cover" or "waive" your deductible
  • No written contract or warranty
  • Can't give you a certification number or an insurance certificate
  • Wants full payment up front

Next step

Get a ballpark price yourself with Build My Price, or book a free drone-documented inspection by calling or texting (608) 897-5377. If you're comparing quotes, bring them along and we'll walk you through what's different.

Call Text